Best-looking Shingle Colors Of 2025

Robert Moore By: Robert Moore

It might be time to get that new roof installed, but first, you need to choose a color. That’s not always the easiest thing to do. It’s almost akin to choosing a paint color — except this decision is going to be on your house for the next 25-50 years and visible from the street every single day.

Here in Tulsa, color choice isn’t just about looks. Darker shingles absorb more heat — and when it’s 95 degrees outside, shingle surface temps on a dark roof can hit 150 degrees or higher. That heat radiates into your attic all day. Lighter and medium-tone shingles reflect more solar energy and run cooler — and if energy efficiency matters to you, look for shingles with an Energy Star rating when you’re comparing products. If your attic ventilation isn’t dialed in, a darker shingle can work against you in the summer months. Something worth factoring in before you fall in love with a color.

That said, the right color still comes down to your specific house — brick tone, siding color, trim, and neighborhood. Since there are several shingle manufacturers, each offering dozens of color options, we put together our top picks based on what we’ve seen look best on Tulsa homes. Use this as a starting point to narrow your search.

Our top 5 picks:

  1. CertainTeed Landmark in Max Def Georgetown Gray

If you want to lighten up the color of your house plus have plenty of color variation, Max Def Georgetown Gray is our top pick. Works especially well on homes with red or tan brick — the gray cools down the overall look without going flat. This is our number one pick.

  1. Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration in Storm Cloud

Do you think your house looks a little dull? This will help brighten it up and add an enormous amount of color. Works well on homes with lighter siding colors cream, beige, or white — where you want the roof to add contrast without going too dark.

  1. CertainTeed Landmark in Max Def Weathered Wood

The yellows and browns just pop on this shingle, but at the same time the colors blend perfectly. Best on homes with natural wood accents, cedar siding, or warm-toned brick. One of the most popular colors we install in the Tulsa area.

  1. Malarkey Vista in Midnight Black

Are you looking for a darker-colored shingle but still want plenty of color variation? This is a great choice. Best suited for homes with lighter exteriors — white, gray, or light brick — where the contrast works in your favor. If you go this route, make sure your ventilation is solid.

  1. Malarkey Legacy in Weathered Wood

This shingle color is smooth-looking. It doesn’t have a lot of variances in color, but it’s elegant and blends in nicely with the dark shadow lines. A good fit for traditional-style homes where you want the roof to complement rather than stand out.

These picks are based on our experience working with homeowners throughout Tulsa and surrounding areas. Still not sure what works for your house? Give Green Country Roofing a call at (918) 607-7409. We’re happy to talk through options before you commit to anything.

Free Inspection

Not sure what your roof needs? We'll come out, take a look, and give you a straight answer — no pressure.

918-607-7409

CERTIFICATIONS

✓ Atlas PRO+ Silver Select

✓ BBB Accredited

✓ ShingleMaster Certified

✓ Licensed & Insured

✓ Free Estimates